Tim Urban

Tonight on Idol Tim sang Under My Thumb to add to Rolling Stones night. Here was the overall feeling from the judges:

Randy-felt that he just didn’t get it, it was just weird for him

Ellen- started by booing herself first and then said she felt like she was at a resort drinking a pina colda. She got it and there was nothing wrong with it but it just didn’t wow her.

Kara totally got what they were saying but on the other side she had to commend him for doing something totally different with the song.

Simon applauded him for doing something different as well. Having said that, it didn’t work. It just doesn’t work doing that song in that version.

Be sure to check back soon for the video from tonight!

Vote for Tim– His number is 1-866-idols-07